Hey!
A company is really just a group of people working towards the same goal. Strategy matters, of course, but the further I get in business, the more convinced I am that the biggest variable in whether you actually get there is the people you have around you. Hiring is the highest leverage thing a founder can do, and most of us get it wrong at the start.
I certainly did. When you first start out, you hire anyone who’s willing to do the job. You usually can’t afford proper salaries, so you lean on people who’ll do you a favour or who genuinely believe in what you’re trying to build. If I’m honest, when we started D.LOUISE I didn’t have a clue what I was doing. There were no job specs and no process, just gut feel and a sense that we needed more hands.
If I started another business tomorrow, I’d move so much faster, not because I’m any smarter, but because I now have a clear hiring framework. So this week I want to walk you through it, step by step, from deciding whether you’re ready to hire through to what happens as the business grows.
Step 1: Decide whether you’re ready to hire
The first question isn’t who to hire, it’s whether you should hire at all, and for me that’s a financial decision. The simplest way to frame it is return on invested capital: you bring someone into the business because you believe you’ll get more back from their time than the salary you pay them.
That return can come directly, because they drive revenue, or indirectly, because they free up your time so you can drive more sales and growth yourself. If you genuinely believe one of those is true, you’re ready to make the hire. If you can’t make that case, you probably aren’t yet.
Step 2: Work out what to hand off
Once you know you’re ready, the next step is deciding which work leaves your plate first. My advice is to start with the low leverage work. In an ecommerce business that’s usually customer service. It matters, but it’s almost certainly not where your genius lies, so handing it off buys back your time, and at this stage that time should go straight back into product or marketing.
Two other lenses help here. First, most founders are good at one of two things: either they can create products the market wants, or they’re great at selling them. Whichever camp you’re in, look to pair yourself with someone who covers the areas you’re weaker in, which for most founders means finance and operations.
Second, look at which tasks give you energy and which ones drain it. I get my energy from being on my own with my thoughts rather than from other people, so I’ve deliberately built my businesses so that I don’t have too many direct reports. If you’re more extroverted, you might be happy spending days of the week in one to ones, and your structure could look completely different. Build the team around how you actually work best, not how you think a CEO is supposed to work.
Step 3: Decide what kind of person you need
I find it helpful to think about every hire on two layers: will and skill. At the beginning, you need will. You need generalists who are happy to get their hands dirty, people you can share the vision with who’ll run at it alongside you.
Because you can usually only afford junior salaries at this stage, you’re hiring people who’ll figure things out as they go. That makes problem solving the single most important trait to look for. Alongside that, I always look for four things: work ethic, energy (will this person give me energy or take it away?), intelligence and ambition.
Step 4: Put it on paper
Before you post anything, get very clear on what you want this person to do and write it all down. That means a proper job spec, even if the role is a generalist one and what you really need is a problem solver, and a 30, 60 and 90 day plan so you both know what success looks like from day one. If you can’t write it down, you’re probably not ready to hire.
Step 5: Screen for problem solving
In the first screening round, where candidates submit a task or answer a few questions, here’s a little trick I use. Ask them: “What’s your typing speed?”
If they reply “I don’t know”, or just “fast”, it suggests they might not be the problem solver you need. The right person will Google a typing test, take it, and come back to you with an actual number. It’s a tiny question, but it shows you exactly how someone behaves when they don’t know the answer, and in an early stage business nobody knows the answer most of the time.
Step 6: Test them on the real job
For the candidates who get through, I’ll always set a task based on the actual role, and one of the best tells is which metrics they choose to look at. If you’re hiring for customer service, for example, a basic candidate will talk about first response times and your Trustpilot score.
A great candidate will go much deeper: contact rate per order, so you can see whether tickets are growing faster than sales; the reasons behind tickets, so you can fix problems at the root; returns broken down by category and reason; the cost to serve each order; and how they’d use AI to handle the repetitive questions so the team can focus on the conversations that really need a human. That’s someone who will improve the function rather than just run it, and one of the biggest lessons I’ve learnt is that the best people need very little management.
Step 7: Expect the team to evolve
The last step is accepting that your first team won’t necessarily be your forever team. As the business grows, you need more specialists: people with track records, people with contacts, people who reduce risk. Time and time again, the people who got you to £1m aren’t the people who get you to £10m, and that’s completely fine.
That doesn’t mean people can’t develop and grow with you. Of course they can, and as a leader it’s your job to put them in the best possible position to do that, if they want to.
The short version
Hire when you believe the return outweighs the salary
Hand off low leverage work first to buy back your time
Early on, hire for will and problem solving over experience
Write the job spec and 30, 60, 90 day plan before you post
Screen for how people behave when they don’t know the answer
Test on the real job and watch which metrics they reach for
Expect the team to change as you scale
A company is just people. Get the people right, and most of your other problems get a lot easier.
Jack
P.S. Some of the most valuable conversations I’ve had while building D.LOUISE were with founders a few steps ahead of me. They saved me years of mistakes, and this is my way of paying that forward. I work 1:1 with a small number of founders each month, so if you’re building a brand and want someone in your corner, you can apply here.